| Team Name | Division(s) | W-L-T | Rating | Details |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
13-3-1 |
94.12 |
 |
| St. Catharines Athletics 2 |
- |
0-3-1 |
82.10 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
11-14-0 |
92.93 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
15-8-0 |
90.20 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
5-16-3 |
93.07 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
4-14-1 |
78.43 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
15-10-4 |
97.76 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
13-8-1 |
84.26 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
9-15-2 |
95.58 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
10-10-1 |
86.31 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
14-11-0 |
97.76 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
3-9-3 |
87.76 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
|
14-3-3 |
97.10 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
|
1-14-3 |
89.59 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
|
19-1-0 |
99.99 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
|
8-4-1 |
87.35 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
|
8-4-0 |
95.55 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
|
0-10-1 |
89.64 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
- |
8-6-2 |
92.85 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
- |
7-8-1 |
85.15 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
- |
7-6-2 |
84.46 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
- |
0-13-0 |
65.52 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
- |
7-5-1 |
95.12 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 2 |
- |
6-8-0 |
80.22 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
8-5-2 |
93.12 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
9-4-0 |
95.40 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
5-5-0 |
77.30 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
4-8-0 |
79.07 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics 1 |
- |
6-4-1 |
93.08 |
 |
| St Catherines Athletics 2 |
- |
2-5-3 |
74.28 |
 |
| St Catharines Athletics |
- |
10-0-0 |
99.99 |
 |
| St. Catharines Athletics |
- |
0-0-0 |
0.00 |
 |